On Mon, Jun 27, 2005 at 02:24:04AM -0700,
magnus at itkonsult-olsen.com wrote:
> Hi
>> I still alot pissoff hotlix they are still breaking
> gpl
I also don't particularly like what they are doing,
but I don't think that they are breaking the GPL.
> see GPL Licen paragraph 2.c
> If the modified program normally reads commands
> interactively when run, you must cause it, when
> started running for such interactive use in the most
> ordinary way, to print or display an announcement
(emphasis)
> including an appropriate copyright notice and a
> notice that there is no warranty (or else, saying
> that you provide a warranty) and that users may
> redistribute the program under these conditions, and
> telling the user how to view a copy of this License.
(/emphasis)
> (Exception: if the Program itself is interactive but
> does not normally print such an announcement, your
> work based on the Program is not required to print
> an announcement.)
>>> Hotlix have replace there copyright note on every
> dll and exe files at run time. ReactOS are
> interactive when it start and therefore are you not
> allown to change the copyright note.
Sorry, but you're making a logical jump. The license
above says that the modified program must display
an *appropriate* copyright notice -- it does not say
that the notice can't be changed. Your definition of
appropriate (i.e., saying the original dev's name) may
not be the legal definition (e.g., the most
significant
contributor, the latest contributor, the second
developer's third-neice-twice-removed's boyfriend's
dog, or whatever). So, from the checklist:
1. Do they print a copyright notice that is
appropriate?
2. Do they print that the program is GPL-licensed?
3. Do they print how to view the license terms?
They appear to comply (or can easily comply with) 2
and 3. Unless you have a lawyer, though, 1 is gray.
> When you take
> view propites of a dll / exe / sys / .. we are
> showing our copyright. therefor are you not allown
> to change this copyright note.
(see above -- same error)
> and they are breaking paragraph
> 4. You may not copy, modify, sublicense, or
> distribute the Program except as expressly provided
> under this License. Any attempt otherwise to copy,
> modify, sublicense or distribute the Program is
> void, and will automatically terminate your rights
> under this License. However, parties who have
> received copies, or rights, from you under this
> License will not have their licenses terminated so
> long as such parties remain in full compliance.
>>> They are not allown to change any licen from us.
Please clarify. According to them, they are using the
GPL license -- same as us. I don't see how they are
changing the licensing.
> for we using sublicen wine dll are lgpl and our own
> code are gpl thefor should wine dll see as a
> sublicen.
I don't really understand what you're trying to say
here. However, note that the LGPL allows you to
"upgrade" to the GPL license (it's effectively a
dual license). The LGPL states:
3. You may opt to apply the terms of the ordinary GNU
General Public License instead of this License to a
given copy of the Library. To do this, you must alter
all the notices that refer to this License, so that
they refer to the ordinary GNU General Public License,
version 2, instead of to this License. (If a newer
version than version 2 of the ordinary GNU General
Public License has appeared, then you can specify that
version instead if you wish.) Do not make any other
change in these notices.
Thus, there is no sublicensing going on -- it's all
one license (GPL).
> I have not check see if they are still breaking more
> paragraph in gpl. And I start thinking to we or I
> should send a email say at they have break gpl and
> they are not longer right to use our code or my.
As irate as you may be, nothing that you've brought up
thus far looks to be an infraction of the GPL
(although they could *potentially* be breaking some
copyright law or other, e.g. by adding their copyright
notices and removing existing ones, or by failing to
cite sources of patches).
> I need get this out from my head and hart. I am alot
> pissoff on holtix guys. The taking our patch and put
> into there source there. without telling how have
> wrote the code.
I agree that that's wrong and unfair. People deserve
credit and recognition for the work that they do.
> That mean they are breaking some copyright laws.
If you can find the particular law that applies, go
for it. I'm not an international lawyer myself, so
I don't know what laws even apply to them -- let alone
if they're breaking those laws.
> You can not take other source code
> and put into another there without writen
> permitontion
You contributed your code under the terms of the GPL.
That is your "written permission," sorry to say -- by
your own choice of license, the source code is
available to be copied, reworked, and re-released by
anyone else. I'll also reiterate that they do seem
to be in compliance (though only by words and not in
spirit).
> or tell where the code comes from. if
> you look at there source there you will think they
> have wrote the patch code. But it is some devloper
> at us that have write the patch for reactos.
Sigh.
-- Travis
__________________________________
Yahoo! Mail Mobile
Take Yahoo! Mail with you! Check email on your mobile phone.
http://mobile.yahoo.com/learn/mail
More information about the Ros-dev
mailing list
CHAPTER VII. THE FOUR CLASSES OF SOCIETY. THE FOUR CLASSES OF SOCIETY. "After the herald had given the names of the wrestlers who were to make the first round, the fellows came in. They were dressed without any clothes to speak of, or rather they were quite undressed, with the exception of a cloth around their loins. They came in on opposite sides of the ring, and stood there about five feet apart, each man resting his hands on his knees, and glaring at the other like a wild beast. They[Pg 231] looked more like a pair of tigers than human beings, and for a moment I thought it was not at all unlike what a bull-fight in Spain might be. I turned upon her choking with anger, but her melting beauty rendered me helpless. Black woods were on our left. "Shall we turn in here?" I asked. "None of that with me," he growled. "Do you know who I am, Countess Lalage? I am Leon Lagage, Count of the Holy Roman Empire, and your husband. Incomparable woman, you cannot alter that fact. For better or worse, for richer or poorer, till death do us part!" I have in this way imperfectly indicated a methodical plan of generating a design, as far as words alone will serve, beginning with certain premises based upon a particular work to be performed, and then proceeding to consider in consecutive order the general character of the machine, mode of operation, movements and adjustments, general arrangement, strains, special arrangement, and proportions. ‘Alas! what is life, what is death, what are we, 11th January two best dresses. Commencement was as usual, with a few showers “All right,” agreed Sandy. “Dick, you and I are the ground crew. As soon as you’re ready, Mr. Whiteside, we’ll take hold!” Effects of Walpole's Administration—Formation of the new Ministry—Attitude of the Malcontents—Committee of Inquiry into Walpole's Administration—Walpole's Protectors—Ministerial Measures—Prorogation of Parliament—Disasters of the French—British Division in the Netherlands—Opening of Parliament—The German Mercenaries—Amendment of the Gin Act—George goes to Germany—Stair and De Noailles in Franconia—Stair in a Trap—Bold Resolution of King George—The Battle of Dettingen—Resignation of Stair—Retreat of the French—Negotiations for Peace—Treaty of Worms—Pelham becomes Prime Minister—The Attacks of Pitt on Carteret—Attempted Invasion of England—Its Failure—Progress of the French Arms—Frederick II. invades Bohemia—His Retirement—Resignation of Carteret—Pelham strengthens his Ministry—Death of the Emperor—Campaign in Flanders—Battle of Fontenoy—Campaign of Frederick II.—The Young Pretender's Preparations—Loss of the Elizabeth—Landing in the Hebrides—The Highland Clans join him—The First Brush—Raising of the Standard—Cope's Mistake—He turns aside at Dalwhinnie—Charles makes a Dash for Edinburgh—The March to Stirling—Right of the Dragoons—The "Canter of Coltbridge"—Edinburgh surprised by the Highlanders—Charles marching against Cope—Battle of Prestonpans—Delay in marching South—Discontent of the Highland Chiefs—The Start—Preparations in England—Apathy of the Aristocracy—Arrival of the Duke of Cumberland—Charles crosses the Border—Capture of Carlisle—The March to Derby—Resolution to retreat—"Black Friday"—The Retreat—Recapture of Carlisle—Siege of Stirling—Battle of Falkirk—Retreat to the Highlands—Cumberland's Pursuit—Gradual Collapse of the Highlanders—Battle of Culloden—Termination of the Rebellion—Cruelty of the Duke of Cumberland—Adventures of the Young Pretender—Trials and Executions—Ministerial Crisis. The next morning he was up betimes, and cooked the boys as good a breakfast as he could out of the remainder of his store and what he could get from the hospital, and then gave what was left to whoever came. The comfortable crib, which had cost the Deacon so much labor, had been pre-empted by the Surgeon for some of his weakest patients. "You two step forward one pace," he commanded. "Gentleman, I've got my six. The rest are yours." "Where are you goin'?" he said sternly. Every now and then the crowd would break into the latest rhymings of MacKinnon's poet: A large thicket, at this moment, gave the dusty foot an opportunity of doubling, and, for an instant, diverging from the straightforward course, though it availed him little, he seemed to feel the breath of his pursuer on the back of his neck; his foot sounded as if at his heels; he drew his garment closely around him, turned suddenly to the right, and, bounding from the ground, the next instant a splash was heard in the little river, and the fugitive was safe from his pursuer. HoME明日之后怎么免费刷一级纳米材料
ENTER NUMBET 0018songsi.org.cn www.saoai.com.cn mtconnect.org.cn ywcfq.com.cn www.pzdiy.com.cn www.wpku58sy.com.cn www.ngud.com.cn www.cowa.org.cn tpjv.com.cn www.hkbus.com.cn